Resilience of human brain functional coactivation networks under thresholding

Recent studies have demonstrated the existence of community structure and rich club nodes, (i.e., highly interconnected, high degree hub nodes), in human brain functional networks. The cognitive relevance of the detected modules and hubs has also been demonstrated, for both task based and default mode networks, suggesting that the brain selforganizes into patterns of co-activated sets of regions for performing specific tasks or in resting state. In this paper, we report studies on the resilience or robustness of this modular structure: under systematic erosion of connectivity in the network under thresholding, how resilient is the modularity and hub structure? The results show that the network shows show strong resilience properties, with the modularity and hub structure maintaining itself over a large range of connection strengths. Then, at a certain critical threshold that falls very close to 0, the connectivity, the modularity, and hub structure suddenly break down, showing a phase transition like property. Additionally, the spatial and topological organization of erosion of connectivity at all levels was found to be homogenous rather than heterogenous; i.e., no “structural holes” of any significant sizes were found, and no gradual increases in numbers of components were detected. Any loss of connectivity is homogenously spread out across the network. The results suggest that human taskbased functional brain networks are very resilient, where the whole network structure fails only when connectivity is almost fully removed from the network. The findings may help further the understanding of dynamics of and relationships between structural and functional brain networks.